Warning to employers over holiday pay after landmark ruling

By KMC Human Resources

06 Nov 2014

Employers who pay staff overtime are being warned that they may have to include any extra hours worked when calculating holiday pay, after a landmark ruling on 4 November 2014.

The decision in 3 cases - Bear Scotland v Fulton and Baxter, Hertel (UK) Ltd v Wood and others; and Amec Group Ltd v Law and others - has been long-awaited by UK businesses, who will going forward have to allow for overtime when calculating employees’ holiday pay.

The claimants argued that they were required to consistently work overtime and that they therefore received considerably less pay when they had taken time off on annual leave than in normal working months.

Since the introduction of the Working Time Directive in 1998, the interpretation in the UK in relation to holiday pay was that employees would be entitled to 4 weeks’ paid holiday, with the rate of pay calculated as per their basic salary. The ruling from the EAT (Employment Appeal Tribunal) implies that UK businesses have been misinterpreting the directive and that actually, employers need to take other factors, such as overtime, into consideration.

Karen Credie of KMC HR commented: “This landmark ruling is something that all employers need to take note of. Whilst most businesses will have been duly paying staff for periods of holiday entitlement based on their basic salary, this will need to be addressed going forward to take into account the revised rules”.

Mike Emmott, employee relations adviser at the CIPD, said: “The UK government and employers have been acting in good faith in implementing the terms of the Working Time Directive over how holiday pay is calculated and it is disappointing the scope for ambiguity was not identified at a much earlier stage.”

The cases in the tribunal were based on claims for non-guaranteed overtime and a distinction was drawn between this and voluntary overtime, the latter of which was not directly addressed in the judgement.

Karen explains: “Non-guaranteed overtime is defined as time worked in addition to set working hours that there is no obligation for employers to provide but there is an obligation for employees to perform it if requested. Voluntary overtime, on the other hand, is where there is no contractual obligation for employees to work additional hours."

Whilst the news is not good for businesses, it does at least seem that they will be unlikely to face substantive retrospective claims from employees, as previously feared. The judgment confirms that claims for back pay will be out of time if there has been a break of more than 3 months between successive underpayments.

It is likely that the EAT decision will face appeal and it may therefore be some time until a definitive conclusion on the topic will be reached. But with further decisions due on whether commission, shift allowances and some types of bonuses should also be included in holiday pay calculations, this is certainly one for employers to keep a very close eye on. Karen concluded: “The advice on calculation of holiday pay remains unclear in some parts and employers should be advised to seek advice if they are at all unsure."

Latest news

1

Azets in new director appointment at Lancaster office Susanna Cassey Azets

Azets in new director appointment at Lancaster office

19 Nov 2026

2

Finalists revealed for Taste Lancashire Producer Awards

Finalists revealed for Taste Lancashire Producer Awards

19 Nov 2026

3

BAE Systems looks to cut more than 1,000 roles bae-systems-typhoon-1.jpg

BAE Systems looks to cut more than 1,000 roles

18 Nov 2026

4

'Red Rose Award win brought me new business', sponsors evening hears Dsc0918

'Red Rose Award win brought me new business', sponsors evening hears

18 Nov 2026

5

Together Housing in 'world first' green energy project Together261026035

Together Housing in 'world first' green energy project

17 Nov 2026

Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
LBV131 November/December Magazine Networking Event
LBV131 Magazine Launch Social720No Text 19 Nov 2026

LBV131 November/December Magazine Networking Event

The Landmark, School Lane, Burnley, BB11 1UF

08:30 - 10:30

Lancashire Business Day 2026
LBD26 WW Logo720 27 Nov 2026

Lancashire Business Day 2026

Burnley Football Club, BB10 4BX

12:00 - 17:00

Sub36 Reunion & Networking
03 Dec 2026

Sub36 Reunion & Networking

Burnley Football Club, BB10 4BX

15:00 - 17:00

Lancashire Net Zero Conference 2027
NZC27 Social 1200x800Generic 1 11 Feb 2027

Lancashire Net Zero Conference 2027

The Wellbeing Farm, Edgworth, Wheatsheaf Hill Farm, Plantation Road, BL7 0BY

09:30 - 02:00

Help to Grow: Management Course
Help To Grow 25 Sep 2026 - 15 Dec 2026

Help to Grow: Management Course

University of Lancashire, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:30 - 12:00

Great Winter Pie & Pea Social
Lancaster And Morecambe Logo 1 19 Nov 2026

Great Winter Pie & Pea Social

The Royal Hotel & Bar, Lancaster, LA1 1YD

17:30 - 20:00

Neurodiversity at Work - A Free Event
Event graphic 1200x800@1x.png.png 20 Nov 2026

Neurodiversity at Work - A Free Event

Lancashire FA, Leyland , PR252LF

09:30 - 12:30

Neurodiversity Awareness and Support Training
20 Nov 2026

Neurodiversity Awareness and Support Training

Neuro Spark Training Solutions, Burnley , BB11 2AS

09:00 - 16:00

Degree Apprenticeship Careers Fair
LBV Website Events GraphicCareers Fair 21 Nov 2026

Degree Apprenticeship Careers Fair

University of Lancashire, Foster Building, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:00 - 15:00

Freelancer Meet-Up: November
 Freelancer Meet-Up Square NOV.png.png 24 Nov 2026

Freelancer Meet-Up: November

Society1, Coworking Space, Preston, PR1 3LT

10:00 - 12:00

The Marketing Meetup : Lancashire
TMM Lancashire 25 Nov 2026

The Marketing Meetup : Lancashire

Six Connections, One Slater Terrace, Burnley, BB11 1BU

18:00 - 20:00

Bank of England North West Economic Update – Autumn Briefing
Lancaster And Morecambe Logo 1 25 Nov 2026

Bank of England North West Economic Update – Autumn Briefing

Lancaster Golf Club, Lancaster, LA2 0AJ

08:30 - 10:30

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more LBV131 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin