Protected conversations: Panacea or problem?

By Lancashire Business View

01 Feb 2017

Have you tried to have a frank conversation with an employee about their attitude or conduct at work with a suggestion that they leave with a financial incentive - only for it to backfire on you, and the employee then relying on that conversation in a tribunal claim as evidence that you are an unfair or unreasonable employer?

By Emma Swan, partner, and Nahum Eustaquio, paralegal, Knights.

Did you think that when the government introduced the concept of ‘protected conversations’ in July 2013 (under S111A of the Employment Rights Act 1996 (ERA) that you had a solution to the problem if you called it a ‘protected conversation’?

We want to shine the light on the problems with ‘protected conversations’ that we have found employers facing. The government introduced ‘protected conversations’ with the intention of reducing some of the workplace politics that often cause employers headaches in trying to resolve workplace disputes or issues of conduct and performance, to name a few.

This was to facilitate what is often the best solution for both parties: the option of agreeing the termination of the employee’s employment in exchange for the employee giving up their rights to bring employment tribunal proceedings, without the employee being able to use the discussions as evidence in a tribunal if an agreement wasn’t ultimately signed. But we are concerned that this is not the panacea that it was intended to be; there is actually a significant risk that employers will not get the protection they think they will get.

Firstly, the ‘protection’ only applies to ordinary unfair dismissal cases so any allegations of discrimination, whistleblowing or other automatically unfair reasons, for example, would mean that the conversation could be used as evidence in the tribunal against the employer.

Secondly, even in an ordinary unfair dismissal case, there are a wide number of opportunities for an employee to argue that the conversation should be allowed to be admitted as evidence. They can say that the employer said or did something that was improper or was connected with improper behaviour. Whilst an ACAS Code of Practice and Guidance Note provide examples of improper behaviour this isn’t exhaustive or legally binding on a tribunal, so there is a low hurdle for an employee’s lawyer to jump over to get the evidence before the tribunal and turn the evidence on its head to show that the employer was forcing an employee into a corner.

There are still ways of achieving ‘off the record’ chats with employees by having a “without prejudice” discussion but these need to be set up properly with a dispute already existing. It is crucial that the correct steps are taken in terminating the employment relationship and specific advice should be taken on a case-by-case basis. If you are planning to address any issues you have with employees and want to look at reducing risk to the business, then make sure that you handle the situation correctly or you may find yourself having an un-protected conversation!

Latest news

1

David Dunn joins Nybble as business ambassador David Dunn Nybble

David Dunn joins Nybble as business ambassador

20 Nov 2026

2

Landmark moment as Issue 131 is launched Whatsapp Image 2026 11 19 At 125514

Landmark moment as Issue 131 is launched

20 Nov 2026

3

Azets in new director appointment at Lancaster office Adam Hilton Mason Azets

Azets in new director appointment at Lancaster office

19 Nov 2026

4

Finalists revealed for Taste Lancashire Producer Awards

Finalists revealed for Taste Lancashire Producer Awards

19 Nov 2026

5

BAE Systems looks to cut more than 1,000 roles bae-systems-typhoon-1.jpg

BAE Systems looks to cut more than 1,000 roles

18 Nov 2026

Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
Lancashire Business Day 2026
LBD26 WW Logo720 27 Nov 2026

Lancashire Business Day 2026

Burnley Football Club, BB10 4BX

12:00 - 17:00

Sub36 Reunion & Networking
03 Dec 2026

Sub36 Reunion & Networking

Burnley Football Club, BB10 4BX

15:00 - 17:00

Lancashire Net Zero Conference 2027
NZC27 Social 1200x800Generic 1 11 Feb 2027

Lancashire Net Zero Conference 2027

The Wellbeing Farm, Edgworth, Wheatsheaf Hill Farm, Plantation Road, BL7 0BY

09:30 - 02:00

Help to Grow: Management Course
Help To Grow 25 Sep 2026 - 15 Dec 2026

Help to Grow: Management Course

University of Lancashire, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:30 - 12:00

Freelancer Meet-Up: November
 Freelancer Meet-Up Square NOV.png.png 24 Nov 2026

Freelancer Meet-Up: November

Society1, Coworking Space, Preston, PR1 3LT

10:00 - 12:00

The Marketing Meetup : Lancashire
TMM Lancashire 25 Nov 2026

The Marketing Meetup : Lancashire

Six Connections, One Slater Terrace, Burnley, BB11 1BU

18:00 - 20:00

Bank of England North West Economic Update – Autumn Briefing
Lancaster And Morecambe Logo 1 25 Nov 2026

Bank of England North West Economic Update – Autumn Briefing

Lancaster Golf Club, Lancaster, LA2 0AJ

08:30 - 10:30

Seriun Cyber Round Table
Seriun-Roundable-3.png.png 25 Nov 2026

Seriun Cyber Round Table

Albert’s Standish, School Ln, Standish, Wigan, WN6 0TD

11:00 - 14:30

Sales Club with Sales Geek
26 Nov 2026 - 26 Nov 2026

Sales Club with Sales Geek

Accrington Stanley Football Club, Accrington, BB5 5BX

08:30 - 11:30

Action Members December Event
Gemini_Generated_Image_4zxpmz4zxpmz4zxp.jpeg.jpg 01 Dec 2026

Action Members December Event

The Wellsprings, Howell Croft South, Bolton , BL1 1SB

09:15 - 11:45

RevTech 2026: Lancashire's biggest AI and revenue technology event
Rev-Tech-2026-Lancashire-Business-View-1200x800.jpg.jpg 02 Dec 2026

RevTech 2026: Lancashire's biggest AI and revenue technology event

Secret venue, revealed to confirmed attendees, Lancashire, TBC

08:30 - 12:30

Chamber Breakfast Networking – December
Lancaster And Morecambe Logo 1 02 Dec 2026

Chamber Breakfast Networking – December

The Dukes, More lane, Lancaster, LA1 1QE

08:00 - 10:00

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more LBV131 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin