Harrison Drury wins landmark case for construction sector

By Harrison Drury

12 Sep 2013

Harrison Drury has won a landmark case at the High Court that is likely to have significant repercussions for the UK construction industry.

The firm has successfully represented Parkwood Leisure Ltd in a claim against construction giant Laing O’Rourke which was heard in the Technology and Construction Court.

Parkwood Leisure Ltd is responsible for operating and managing Cardiff International Pool. The facility was designed and built by Laing O’Rourke. While Parkwood was not a party to the main construction contract, it has the benefit of a collateral warranty from Laing O’Rourke in respect of the design and building works.

It was previously the position that collateral warranties did not fall within the statutory definition of construction contracts and therefore could not be adjudicated under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996. Adjudication is a procedure for resolving disputes without resorting to lengthy and expensive court proceedings.

However, this case has confirmed that in certain circumstances a collateral warranty can fall within the definition of a “construction contract” for the purposes of s104 of the Housing, Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996. The effect of this is that statutory adjudication is now potentially available for resolving warranty claims as an alternative to formal court proceedings.

Colin Fenny, associate solicitor at Harrison Drury, who represented Parkwood Leisure, said: “The decision will have serious implications for the construction industry because it extends the use of the adjudication procedure in principle to parties that are not directly involved in the underlying construction project where they have the benefit of an appropriately worded warranty from the contractor.

“Adjudication presents a much speedier and cheaper option for claimants to seek remedy for construction disputes compared to formal court proceedings, and while only certain warranties will fall within the scope of this decision, it could lead to an increased use of this procedure for the resolution of warranty claims at least in relation to existing warranties. It could significantly speed up the resolution of disputes to the benefit of the construction industry generally in delivering buildings without costly delays and disputes as the economy picks up.”

“In the longer term I expect that the decision is also inevitably going to lead to a greater reluctance on contractors to provide collateral warranties to third parties in the future, or at least limit the scope and extent of any warranties they are prepared to give.”

Earlier this year, Parkwood Leisure Limited intimated a claim to Laing O”Rourke under its collateral warranty. The claim related to alleged defects in the system which controls air quality at the facility. Laing O’Rourke denied any liability and rejected Parkwood’s proposal that the parties voluntarily refer the claim to adjudication for resolution on the basis that the adjudication procedure was not available for collateral warranty claims.

To avoid any subsequent issues arising over whether an adjudicator had the jurisdiction to determine a collateral warranty claim, Parkwood sought a declaration in the Technology and Construction Court that the collateral warranty was a “construction contract” and therefore satisfied the qualifying requirements for the statutory adjudication procedure.

In his judgement of the case, heard on August 23, Mr Justice Akenhead ruled that where a collateral warranty was “for…the carrying out of construction operations” it could be construed as a “construction contract” and therefore be subject to statutory adjudication.

On the terms of the collateral warranty in question, Mr Justice Akenhead had “no doubt” that it was “for…the carrying out of construction operations” and should therefore be treated as a construction contract. The ruling means that Parkwood Leisure Ltd can now refer its warranty claim in respect of the air quality system to adjudication for determination. Harrison Drury will continue to represent the firm in this process.

Latest news

1

Azets in new director appointment at Lancaster office Adam Hilton Mason Azets

Azets in new director appointment at Lancaster office

19 Nov 2026

2

Finalists revealed for Taste Lancashire Producer Awards

Finalists revealed for Taste Lancashire Producer Awards

19 Nov 2026

3

BAE Systems looks to cut more than 1,000 roles bae-systems-typhoon-1.jpg

BAE Systems looks to cut more than 1,000 roles

18 Nov 2026

4

'Red Rose Award win brought me new business', sponsors evening hears Dsc0918

'Red Rose Award win brought me new business', sponsors evening hears

18 Nov 2026

5

Together Housing in 'world first' green energy project Together261026035

Together Housing in 'world first' green energy project

17 Nov 2026

Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Leverage Lancashire Business View platforms

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Build your network
Improve your SEO
Gain coverage in the magazine
Sign-up
Events
Lancashire Business Day 2026
LBD26 WW Logo720 27 Nov 2026

Lancashire Business Day 2026

Burnley Football Club, BB10 4BX

12:00 - 17:00

Sub36 Reunion & Networking
03 Dec 2026

Sub36 Reunion & Networking

Burnley Football Club, BB10 4BX

15:00 - 17:00

Lancashire Net Zero Conference 2027
NZC27 Social 1200x800Generic 1 11 Feb 2027

Lancashire Net Zero Conference 2027

The Wellbeing Farm, Edgworth, Wheatsheaf Hill Farm, Plantation Road, BL7 0BY

09:30 - 02:00

Help to Grow: Management Course
Help To Grow 25 Sep 2026 - 15 Dec 2026

Help to Grow: Management Course

University of Lancashire, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:30 - 12:00

Neurodiversity at Work - A Free Event
Event graphic 1200x800@1x.png.png 20 Nov 2026

Neurodiversity at Work - A Free Event

Lancashire FA, Leyland , PR252LF

09:30 - 12:30

Neurodiversity Awareness and Support Training
20 Nov 2026

Neurodiversity Awareness and Support Training

Neuro Spark Training Solutions, Burnley , BB11 2AS

09:00 - 16:00

Degree Apprenticeship Careers Fair
LBV Website Events GraphicCareers Fair 21 Nov 2026

Degree Apprenticeship Careers Fair

University of Lancashire, Foster Building, Preston, PR1 2HE

09:00 - 15:00

Freelancer Meet-Up: November
 Freelancer Meet-Up Square NOV.png.png 24 Nov 2026

Freelancer Meet-Up: November

Society1, Coworking Space, Preston, PR1 3LT

10:00 - 12:00

The Marketing Meetup : Lancashire
TMM Lancashire 25 Nov 2026

The Marketing Meetup : Lancashire

Six Connections, One Slater Terrace, Burnley, BB11 1BU

18:00 - 20:00

Bank of England North West Economic Update – Autumn Briefing
Lancaster And Morecambe Logo 1 25 Nov 2026

Bank of England North West Economic Update – Autumn Briefing

Lancaster Golf Club, Lancaster, LA2 0AJ

08:30 - 10:30

Seriun Cyber Round Table
Seriun-Roundable-3.png.png 25 Nov 2026

Seriun Cyber Round Table

Albert’s Standish, School Ln, Standish, Wigan, WN6 0TD

11:00 - 14:30

Sales Club with Sales Geek
26 Nov 2026 - 26 Nov 2026

Sales Club with Sales Geek

Accrington Stanley Football Club, Accrington, BB5 5BX

08:30 - 11:30

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more LBV131 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin