Trust and confidence - a critical review of the Tomlinson Report

By Curtis Law Solicitors

16 Dec 2013

Anis Waiz is a banking and finance litigator at Curtis Law Solicitors. In this article he looks at the recent Tomlinson report which highlights a number of serious allegations made against lenders and clarifies a few key important issues raised.

How many people do you trust? Not many I suspect. My natural response is very few, but that’s because I tend to pursue fraudsters.

It is fair to say that our confidence in banks and lenders is under daily scrutiny and a great concern for any business. A recent report titled ‘Banks’ Lending Practices: Treatment of Businesses in Distress,’ makes a number of very serious allegations against one particular lender and its treatment of customer’s assets.

The report clearly forces businesses to question the trust they have with lenders, but in this article I would like to highlight three important issues raised that need further explanation.

Lenders ‘engineering’ defaults

The report looks at certain ways lenders may in effect treat customers as being ‘distressed’ and therefore subject to ‘insolvency’. It does not state how this is achieved but the implications are clear. The idea is that a lender is able to ‘engineer’ a default so that a customer is no longer a viable business.

Firstly it is important to note that a contract between customer and lender will set out the grounds for a customer being in default. This is usually the failure to pay monies on demand; however there are other circumstances that will be listed in the terms of a mortgage, signed by the customer.

Generally it is the demand from a lender that triggers the default and allows action to be taken against a customer. No matter what the motive from the lender, the real issue is a legal one, for example, is the lender entitled to make a demand? In simple terms, that all depends on the terms of a contract.

Sale of assets

A key concern highlighted is that some lenders will simply undervalue assets before selling them off. It’s suggested this is done to distress the business, allowing another party to buy the assets at a discount. Whether or not this is the case, there are some important issues to address.

In general terms, a lender has a duty to obtain a true market value of a property, which is the value that a purchaser is prepared to pay to a willing vendor, after the property has been on the market for a suitable amount of time. As it’s a complex area of law, the case law must be properly considered.

An allegation of undervalue is a serious matter and must be dealt with properly. From the outset it’s important to understand the issue and the need for careful expert evidence as simply alleging that a sale is made at a lower value than appropriate is not sufficient.

Access to legal advice

The report notes that “Any law firm that does business with the banks will have a clause in their contract, preventing them from taking action against the banks. This means that for businesses the pool of solicitors available to give them advice and take their case is extremely limited”.

Firstly, a firm could not act against a bank under the Solicitors Code of Conduct if there is a conflict of interests. Secondly, it states that there are a limited amount of solicitors available to act, however this is not the case as there’s a wealth of highly experienced solicitors who can and will act for such a business.

I began by asking the simple question; who do you trust? When it comes to professionals, we place significant trust and confidence in them. We trust that a pilot will land a place safely; a doctor will prescribe the right medicine and that our banks details are secure.

Our daily lives revolve around trusting others and having confidence in their ability, whether that is in our personal or professional lives. Businesses simply could not function without it.

The report by Mr Tomlinson paints a worrying picture that should be of real concern to the lending industry and lawyers acting in such claims. I hope the issues highlighted help increase the understanding of the wider legal context and emphasise that any allegation requires serious consideration and advice before it’s acted on. If you have concerns with any of these aspects, the first thing you need to do is speak to someone you can trust. Here at Curtis Law, we pride ourselves on being just that.

Enjoyed this? Read more from Curtis Law Solicitors

Latest news

1

Dog greetings card firm lands John Lewis partnership Scoff Cards

Dog greetings card firm lands John Lewis partnership

22 May 2024

2

Online horse health retailer opens larger premises and first shop Hannah Wild

Online horse health retailer opens larger premises and first shop

22 May 2024

3

Net zero: Why SMEs are important Net zero.jpg.jpg

Net zero: Why SMEs are important

22 May 2024

4

Hotfoot designs new website for Cincinnati Shakespeare Company Hotfoot 2.jpeg.jpg

Hotfoot designs new website for Cincinnati Shakespeare Company

22 May 2024

5

Hyndburn's culture and community to connect at special event The Connecting Cultures event will take place at Haworth Art Gallery in June.jpg.jpg

Hyndburn's culture and community to connect at special event

22 May 2024

Lbv116 Ltb Strip980
Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Reach 50,000 members of the Lancashire business community

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Company profile
Social reach
Magazine coverage
Sign-up
Events
Business Networking in Lancaster - Eden Business Network
EVENT LISTING Eden Business Network.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
22 May 2024

Business Networking in Lancaster - Eden Business Network

The Borough, 3 Dalton Square, Lancaster, LA1 1PP

18:30 - 20:30

Business Networking in Accrington - BNI Zeus
EVENT LISTING SIZING Zeus.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
22 May 2024

Business Networking in Accrington - BNI Zeus

The Mill House, Corn Mill Yard, Accrington, BB5 5HX

06:45 - 08:30

Your Business Bootcamp
CBP-logo LBV.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
22 May 2024

Your Business Bootcamp

Burnley Football Club, Turf Moor, 52-56 Harry Potts Way, Burnley, BB10 4BX

08:30 - 13:30

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Diamond
EVENT LISTING BNI Diamond.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
22 May 2024

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Diamond

The Marriot Hotel, Garstang Road, Broughton, PR3 5JB

07:15 - 09:00

Business Networking in Burnley - BNI Kudos
EVENT LISTING BNI Kudos.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
23 May 2024 - 23 May 2024

Business Networking in Burnley - BNI Kudos

Prairie Sports Village, Windemere Avenue, Burnley, BB10 2FU

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Lancaster - BNI Castle
EVENT LISTING BNI Castle.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
23 May 2024 - 23 May 2024

Business Networking in Lancaster - BNI Castle

Vale of Lune RUFC, Powder House Lane, Lancaster, LA1 2TT

06:45 - 08:30

Chamber Breakfast Networking
Chamber Logo1.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
23 May 2024 - 23 May 2024

Chamber Breakfast Networking

HIC, Lancaster University, Bailrigg, Lancaster, LA1 4AT

08:00 - 10:00

Creative Lancashire Networking Social
Untitled design-4.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
23 May 2024

Creative Lancashire Networking Social

Society1 Coworking Space, Preston, PR1 3LT

17:30 - 19:30

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Infinity
EVENT LISTING BNI Infinity.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
24 May 2024

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Infinity

Hampton by Hilton, 2 Frontier Ave, Blackburn, BB1 3AL

06:30 - 08:30

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Brunch
EVENT LISTING SIZING Brunch .png.png
LBV Hub Networking
24 May 2024

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Brunch

Samlesbury Hotel, Preston, PR5 0UL

09:30 - 11:00

Music In the Park
Music in the Park.jpg.jpg
LBV Hub Fundraisers
26 May 2024

Music In the Park

Worden Park, Worden Lane, Leyland, PR25 3DH

12:30 - 22:30

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Vista
EVENT LISTING SIZING Vista.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
28 May 2024

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Vista

Hampton by Hilton, 2 Frontier Ave, Blackburn, BB1 3AL

06:45 - 08:30

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more LBV116 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin