Miliband's university fees plan would kill aspiration

Ed Miliband’s proposal to fund a reduction in university fees by raiding private pension pots will kill off aspiration in the young and has been branded “bonkers” by a Lancashire business advisory and accountancy firm.

Chartered accountant and business development specialist, John Toon, of Blackburn based, Pierce Group, one of the county's largest independent accountancy businesses, believes that Mr Miliband’s plans will be wholly counter-productive by not only creating a funding crisis for higher education but by stifling the future prospects and earnings potential of the very students he professes to support.

In a blog on the subject, he echoes the comments of Money Saving Expert’s Martin Lewis, who has called Ed Miliband’s suggestion, “financially illiterate.” He commented: “University graduates are the most likely to gain careers with salaries that will put them in the higher earnings tax bracket. And, under the new Auto Enrolment pensions’ policy, they’d be required to put 5 per cent of their earnings into a pension for the rest of their working life, yet on higher annual earnings, they would lose around hundreds of pounds each year if pensions’ tax relief is abolished as a consequence of the Labour leader’s proposal to pay for the reduction in tuition fees this way.

“The question I would ask as a student is, do I want my tuition fees reducing now by a third, or do I want to pay say a year on year penalty on my future earnings for life, if I’m fortunate enough to achieve my earnings potential. For me it would be a no-brainer but the only way to avoid the loss of tax relief would be for me to lower my horizons and settle for less from my career. It’s utterly bonkers, because it’s robbing people of aspiration. After all, what’s the point of gaining a university education, if not for the potential for higher earnings and better prospects? To then have those earnings penalised, just to pay for a modest reduction in tuition fees is anti-aspiration and shows the idea simply hasn’t been thought through.” Mr Toon also points out that students benefiting from reduced tuition fees under any future Labour government would still have to service their student loan debt if they earn above the threshold of £21,000 per year and suggests they would actually be worse off in the long-term than they would be if tuition fees remain at their current level and pension tax relief is retained. The consequences for higher education, he suggests, could also be serious in that some courses might be lost, particularly those in fields such as engineering and science where universities incur considerable costs for equipment and materials.

Enjoyed this? Read more from Pierce CA Ltd

Latest news

1

Supermarket stays put in blow to town's £250m masterplan Blackburn Aerial

Supermarket stays put in blow to town's £250m masterplan

28 Mar 2024

2

Modern Milkman acquires American counterpart article placeholder listing image

Modern Milkman acquires American counterpart

28 Mar 2024

3

How the UK’s strategy to reduce net migration affects care work AdobeStock_89838327 (1).jpeg.jpg

How the UK’s strategy to reduce net migration affects care work

28 Mar 2024

4

Dealmakers: Star Tissue takes a leading roll Khalid Saifullah

Dealmakers: Star Tissue takes a leading roll

28 Mar 2024

5

Construction work begins at 53-home development in Earby article placeholder listing image

Construction work begins at 53-home development in Earby

28 Mar 2024

Hwc 2024 Email Signature 980x120
Background image for hub sign up block

LBV Hub

Reach 50,000 members of the Lancashire business community

Post your news
Post your events
Post your offers
Company profile
Social reach
Magazine coverage
Sign-up
Events
Business Networking in Burnley - BNI Kudos
EVENT LISTING BNI Kudos.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
28 Mar 2024

Business Networking in Burnley - BNI Kudos

Prairie Sports Village, Windemere Avenue, Burnley, BB10 2FU

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Lancaster - BNI Castle
EVENT LISTING BNI Castle.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
28 Mar 2024

Business Networking in Lancaster - BNI Castle

Vale of Lune RUFC, Powder House Lane, Lancaster, LA1 2TT

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Brunch
EVENT LISTING SIZING Brunch .png.png
LBV Hub Networking
29 Mar 2024

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Brunch

Samlesbury Preston Hotel, Preston New Road, Preston, PR5 0UL

09:30 - 11:00

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Infinity
EVENT LISTING BNI Infinity.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
29 Mar 2024

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Infinity

Hampton by Hilton, 2 Frontier Ave, Blackburn, BB1 3AL

06:30 - 08:30

Business Networking in Chorley - BNI Endeavour
EVENT LISTING SIZING Endeavour.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
02 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Chorley - BNI Endeavour

Oak Royal, Bury Lane, Chorley, PR6 8SW

06:30 - 08:30

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Vista
EVENT LISTING SIZING Vista.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
02 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Blackburn - BNI Vista

Hampton by Hilton, 2 Frontier Ave, Blackburn, BB1 3AL

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Accrington - BNI Zeus
EVENT LISTING SIZING Zeus.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
03 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Accrington - BNI Zeus

The Mill House, Corn Mill Yard, Accrington, BB5 5HX

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Diamond
EVENT LISTING BNI Diamond.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
03 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Diamond

The Marriot Hotel, Garstang Road, Broughton, PR3 5JB

07:15 - 09:00

Business Networking in Lancaster - Eden Business Network
EVENT LISTING Eden Business Network.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
03 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Lancaster - Eden Business Network

The Borough, 3 Dalton Square, Lancaster, LA1 1PP

18:30 - 20:30

Business Networking in Burnley - BNI Kudos
EVENT LISTING BNI Kudos.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
04 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Burnley - BNI Kudos

Prairie Sports Village, Windemere Avenue, Burnley, BB10 2FU

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Lancaster - BNI Castle
EVENT LISTING BNI Castle.png.png
LBV Hub Networking
04 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Lancaster - BNI Castle

Vale of Lune RUFC, Powder House Lane, Lancaster, LA1 2TT

06:45 - 08:30

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Brunch
EVENT LISTING SIZING Brunch .png.png
LBV Hub Networking
05 Apr 2024

Business Networking in Preston - BNI Brunch

Samlesbury Preston Hotel, Preston New Road, Preston, PR5 0UL

09:30 - 11:00

Advertise with us

Reaching 50,000 members, our print, digital and event platforms offer a fantastic way to raise your business profile and help you grow.

Find out more Lbv115 Online Graphic
Subscribe now

Weekly news bulletin